Chapter 2: Solvent Based Extraction (Part 1: Hydrocarbon Extraction)
,
by Avery Benitez
52 min reading time
INTRODUCTION TO SOLVENT-BASED BOTANICAL EXTRACTION
Botanicalextraction is a fascinating process used widely to create some of the modern products used daily. From medicine to cleaning agents, powerful botanical compounds can be extracted from a wide variety of different plants and used to make a plethora of useful products.
Currently, there are several popularized methods of botanicalextraction in today'sextraction landscape, all of which have their own use cases and unique benefits. Most botanicalextraction methods can be categorized into two different methodologies, eithersolvent-based extraction or solventless-based extraction.
In some cases, target compounds can be concentrated from biomass material utilizing solventless-based extraction techniques centered around mechanical separation methods including Ice water extraction, dry sifting, and Rosin pressing. These methods of extraction are limited in their utility and typically only apply to plants that contain their target compounds within glandular trichomes.
Conversely,solvent-based botanicalextraction methods utilize organicsolvents to dissolve target compounds from botanicalbiomass to form asolution.Solvent-basedextraction methods have a wider array of applicable use cases and allow for greater versatility in an application when it comes tobotanical extract. In this course, we will focus on the two most prominent and applicable forms ofsolvent-basedextraction:hydrocarbon extractionandethanol extraction.
While both methods are highly efficient in extracting botanical compounds, both have their own benefits and drawbacks. When it comes to determining the suitable form ofsolvent-basedextraction for a specific process, it comes down to determining whichsolvent is most compatible with the target compoundspolarity andboiling points, along which process fits the tolerance for potential hazard. This section will explore the basics of howsolvent-based botanicalextraction works and highlight the factors in determining whichsolvent is best for a specific application.
POLARITY
In the world ofsolvents like, dissolves like. Asolvent’s polarity dictates asolvent’s capability to dissolve a target compound frombiomass material. Generally,polar solvents can dissolvepolar compounds, andnonpolar solvents can dissolvenonpolar compounds. When choosing anextraction solvent, it must be compatible with the target compounds’polarity to dissolve them from the botanical plant matter to form asolution.
Solvent-basedextractions rely on the principle ofsolubility in order to extract target compounds from botanicalbiomass.Solubility refers to a compounds' ability to be dissolved by asolvent forming asolution. Asolutionis defined as a homogeneous mixture of two or more substances.
Thesolvent is the major part of thesolution in botanicalextraction. The substance dissolved in thesolvent, referred to as thesolute, is the minor part of thesolution. When asolution has dissolved all it can and can no longer dissolve any moresolute, it is considered asaturated solution.
The compound’ssolubility andsaturation capacity within asolvent can be altered by increasing or decreasing the temperature of thesolvent and orsolution. However, thesolubility of a compound within asolvent is ultimately determined by itspolarity.
A substance’spolarity is determined by the distribution of electron density across the molecular structure of that compound. Compounds that have an even spread of electrons likebutaneandpropanearenonpolar. Compounds with an unevenly shared electron density like water are classified aspolar compounds.
Polar compounds are defined as having both a positive and a negatively charged end. Thepolarity of thesolvent will determine the compounds it can dissolve. While some compounds can be morepolar ornonpolar than others, generally like dissolves like,polar solvents can dissolvepolar compounds, andnonpolar solventscan dissolvenonpolar compounds.
We can calculate a compound'spolarity based on its electronegativity. Electronegativity measures how strongly an atom is attracted to an electron it bonds with. The higher this number, the more an atom of that element will be attracted to electrons in a bond.
Generally, if the compound has an electronegativity <0.4, it is classified as anonpolar covalent bond. If the compound’s electronegativity is between 0.4 and 1.8, it is considered apolar covalent (Polar), and if the electronegativity is greater than 1.8, it is considered an Ionic bond which isnonpolar.
While polarity is typically binary, meaning it is either polar or nonpolar, there are some instances where a compound has both polar and nonpolar properties, like in the case of ethanol. Ethanol's polarity is unique, while its electronegativity classifies it as polar. Due to its structure, ethanol has a hydrotropic polar head(water-loving) that can bind to water-soluble polar compounds and a nonpolar tail that can dissolve hydrophobic or oil-soluble nonpolar compounds that are typically found in botanical biomass. When a compound has both polar and nonpolar properties, it is classified as amphiphilic, meaning it has both hydrophilic and hydrophobic properties.
ETHANOL
Ethanols' amphiphilic nature can be beneficial when making afull spectrumextract containing all the different compounds found within the botanicalbiomass. However, it can make the processes ofbotanical extractrefinement more challenging when trying to make a highly concentratedbotanical extractof a certain compound.
While asolvent’s polarity plays a major role in its ability to dissolve both desirable and undesirable compounds from botanicalbiomass, thesolubility andsaturation capacity of asolvent can be altered to some extent by adjusting the temperature of thesolvent prior toextraction—generally, both thesolubility andsaturation capacity of asolvent increases or decreases along with its temperature.
As the temperature of asolution increases, typically, itssolubility andsaturation capacity also increases. When the temperature of asolvent is decreased, itssolubility andsaturation capacity also decreases. In botanicalextraction, it is quite common for thesolvent to be chilled prior toextraction to alter itsselectivity and limit the co-extraction of undesirable compounds.
DC-40 Inline Ethanol Chiller by Delta Separations
Chillingsolvent prior toextraction reduces both thesolubility target compounds and undesirable plant waxes andchlorophyll. While this is somewhat counterintuitive, chilled can create a higher puritybotanical extract. While the temperature of asolvent plays a role in thesolubility andsaturation capacity of target compounds within asolvent, ultimately, a compound’ssolubility within asolvent is predominantly determined by itspolarity.
When it comes to botanical extraction, compatibility between a solvent's polarity and the target compounds' polarity is essential in extracting the target compounds from botanical biomass. While polarity is quite possibly the most important factor in extracting the target compounds, the solvents boiling point in relation to that of the target compounds will determine the viability of recovering that solvent from the botanical extractsolution.
BOILING POINT
A compound’sboiling pointis defined as the temperature at which thevaporpressure of a liquid equals the atmospheric pressure of the surrounding liquid andphase changesfrom a liquid to avapor observed as boiling. When it comes to asolvent-basedextraction, thesolvent’s boiling pointin relation to the target compounds'boiling pointwill determine the viability of recovering saidsolvent from the botanical extractwithoutevaporating the target compounds.
Asolvent with a lowerboiling pointthan that of the target compounds is ideal toevaporate thesolvent from thebotanical extractsolution effectively. Ideally, there should be a significant difference between thesolvent's boiling pointand the target compound'sboiling points so thesolvent can be easilyevaporated from thesolution without co-evaporating the target compounds.
For instance, if the target compound is cannabidiol, most extraction solvents haveboiling points that are well below the boiling points of cannabidiol (180C/356F), making them easily recoverable from the botanical extract with limited degradation of the target compound, making them considerable candidates. However, higher boiling pointsolvents like ethanolwould not be strong candidates if the target compounds are highly volatile, like terpenes.
50L Neocision Rotary Evaporator Turnkey System By BVV
In this case, recovering the highboiling pointsolvent from the extract would result in the volatilization or conversion of the targetterpenes making it nearly impossible to separate the two throughdistillation. In this case, anonpolar solvent with a lowerboiling pointlikebutaneorpropanewould be a better candidate to extract lowerboiling pointterpenes.
When choosing the rightsolvent to extract target compounds theextraction solvent should have a lowerboiling pointwith a great enough difference between theextraction solvent and the target compoundsboiling points. This will allow thesolvent to be easily recovered from the extract without co-evaporating the target compounds in order for it to be considered a viable method ofextraction.
Once asolventhas been determined to be compatible with the target compounds’polarity andboiling points, the final key factor determining the overall viability of asolvent-based botanicalextraction method for application is its potential hazard. Inherent risks of theextraction method must be considered, the appropriate fire safety measures required, the overall suitability of the facility, and potential zoning or licensing restrictions to determine if anextraction method is viable for the application.
SAFETY
When performing asolvent-basedextraction, safety should always be the number one concern. Typically mostsolvents used for botanicalextraction present an inherent risk due to their flammability and volatility. Although onesolvent may be a prime candidate to extract target compounds, the level of hazard or fire safety requirements may disqualify that method based on the criteria.
While someextraction methods pose more inherent risk than others with the right equipment,solvent-basedextractions can be performed with very little risk posed to the operator or the surrounding area. When performing asolvent-basedextraction with flammable and volatilesolvents, the best way to mitigate risk is to performsolvent-basedextraction methods within an appropriately rated hazardous location.
Utilizing highly flammablesolvents under extreme temperatures and pressures can be dangerous. To safely and compliantly perform most forms ofsolvent-basedextraction, it must be done in an appropriately rated hazardous location with all the proper safety and protective equipment.
Hazardous locations are areas where the possibility of fire or explosion hazards may exist under normal or abnormal conditions because of the presence of flammable, combustible, or ignitablegases,vapors, liquids, dust, or fibers/flyings. These areas are classified solely for the purpose of ensuring the safe and proper specification and installation of electrical/electronic equipment. Using an appropriately ratedextraction boothorfume hoodgreatly reduces the risks of working with volatile organicsolvents.
C1D1 Explosion-Proof Booth By Advanced Extraction Labs
Hazardous locations fall under three classifications with two separate divisions. Class 1 locations are those in which flammablevapors may be present, Class 2 locations are those in which combustible dust may be found, and class 3 locations are those in which easily ignitable fibers or flyings may be present. Mostsolvent-basedbotanical extractprocessing techniques fall under the first classification due to the possibility of flammablevapors being present.
Depending on the specificbotanical extractprocessing technique it may be classified as division 1 or division 2; these divisions define the likelihood of hazardous materials in a flammable concentration. In a division 1 environment, ignitable concentrations of hazards exist under normal operating conditions or where a hazard is caused by frequent maintenance, repair work, or equipment failure. Division 2 environments are defined as environments where ignitable concentrations of hazards are handled, processed, or used, while normally in closed containers or closed systems from which they can only escape through accidental rupture or breakdown of such containers or systems.
Lower Explosive Limit Gas Detector By Honeywell
Hazardous locations require all electrical/electronics equipment to be designed, tested, and labeled as acceptable for use in the areas where it is installed. Beyond utilizing appropriately rated electrical/electronic components mostextraction areas will come equipped with an explosion-proof exhaust fan providing a high air exchange rate, along with a lower explosive limitgas detector to alert high levels ofgas and trigger an increased rate of exhaust ventilation.
An appropriately ratedextraction booth is a must-have to safely and compliantly performsolvent-basedextraction. It is also required by most local municipalities and therefore should be worked into the budget of every botanicalextraction lab build. Keep in mind that some of the more volatile extractionsolvents likehydrocarbons typically require operation in aC1D1 environmentor may not be allowed within the specific zoning or licensing. It is important to always consult with the local fire marshal to determine the viability and legality of performing certain types ofsolvent-basedextraction methods before building out asolvent-basedextraction lab.
By consulting with a local fire marshal, the exact requirements necessary to performsolvent-basedextraction methods and storesolvent in the facility can be determined. While there are some broad requirements to follow, the local fire marshal will determine the specific requirements for each facility. Now that we have gone over some of the differentiating factors betweensolvent-basedextraction methods, let’s explore thesolvent-basedextraction methods covered in this chapter.
HYDROCARBON EXTRACTION
10LB+ EVO Certified Closed Loop Extractor by BVV
Hydrocarbon extractionis an incredibly versatile method of botanicalextraction.Hydrocarbon solventslikebutaneandpropaneare praised for their relatively high yield and low cost.Hydrocarbons are a classification of organic compounds composed of hydrogen and carbon. These highly volatile compounds are valued for their lowboiling points, making them easily recovered from mostbotanical extracts.
Bothbutane andpropanearenonpolar, making them great candidates to extractnonpolar botanical compounds.Butane andpropane aregaseous at room temperature, and ambient pressure becomes liquid when pressure is increased, or temperature is reduced. Using liquidhydrocarbon solvent tosaturate biomass material can dissolve targetnonpolar compounds and extract them from the plant material. Due tobutane andpropane's lowerboiling points, they lend themselves to preserving highly volatile compounds liketerpenes resulting in a more aromatic and flavorfulbotanical extract.
Hydrocarbon extraction is an excellent option for creating high-quality extracts with decent throughput and relatively low startup cost in comparison to the level of equipment needed to create an ethanol extracted concentrate of similar potency. Although there are many benefits to Hydrocarbon extraction, the main drawback of Hydrocarbonextraction is the solvent's high volatility; hydrocarbons are highly combustible, requiring careful safety measures, including operation within a C1D1extractionbooth. Due to hydrocarbons’ high volatility, this extractionmethod may not be permitted by local municipalities. Be sure to consult with the local fire marshal to determine the viability of this method for zoning or licensing.
ETHANOL EXTRACTION
45L Jacketed Stainless Steel centrifuge By BVV
Ethanol extraction is an excellent method of botanical extraction valued for its high throughput potential and reduced flammability compared to more volatilesolvent-based extraction methods likehydrocarbon extraction.Ethanolis classified as alcohol made from starch-based plant materials through a complex fermentation anddistillation process.Ethanol (EtOH), commonly known as ethyl alcohol or grain alcohol, is a colorless flammable liquid with an incredible number of uses beyond botanicalextraction including fuel and cleaning agent.
As anextraction solvent ethanolis unique due to its amphiphilic nature meaning it has bothpolar andnonpolar properties.Ethanolhas a hydrotropicpolar head(water-loving) that can bind to water-soluble compounds and anonpolar tail that can dissolve hydrophobic or oil-soluble compounds typically found in botanicalbiomass. As the plant matter issaturated withethanol, it dissolves bothpolar andnonpolar compounds from thebiomass material extracting them.Ethanol'samphiphilic nature can be ideal when seeking to create a more full-spectrum product, but it can be less than ideal for those looking to create a more concentrated extract.
Due toethanols'polar andnonpolar nature, it has an increased propensity to co-extract undesirable plant waxes andchlorophyll during theextractionprocess. This typically results in a less potent and pure end product requiring morepost-processingto reach the same purity level than that of anonpolarsolvent likebutane orpropane. Whileethanols’selectivity for undesirable plant waxes andchlorophyll can be altered by chilling theethanol prior toextraction, reducing thesolubility of undesirable plant waxes and color pigments, it also reduces thesolubility of target compounds.
Beyond its polarity, ethanol has a high saturation capacity and only requires a short retention time to dissolve target compounds lending itself to short runtimes and high throughput potential. Ethanol is particularly well suited for bulk processing, with available systems that can extract thousands of pounds of biomass within a single working shift. This makes ethanol a great option for those making botanical extracts at larger scales. Additionally, ethanol is less volatile than hydrocarbons, typically only requiring operation in a C1D2 hazardous location.
Chapter 2: Solvent Based Extraction Glossary
Azeotrope: A mixture of 2 or more liquids, which has a constant shared boiling point and vapor composition through distillation. Biomass: Generic plant matter used in extraction. Composed of flowers, leaves, and other plant parts. Boiling Point: The boiling point of a substance is the temperature at which the vapor pressure of the liquid equals or exceeds the pressure surrounding the liquid causing the liquid to vaporize, observed as boiling. Botanical Extract: An extract created from botanical biomass material. Butane: An organic compound with four-carbon atoms classified as an alkane that is used for extraction.
Centrifuge: A device that uses centrifugal force to separate various compounds within a fluid.
Chlorophyll: A green pigment, present in all green plants that absorb light energy. Closed Loop System: Extraction equipment that contains the solvent within a closed system without exposure to open-air. Crude oil: The yield from an extraction before refinement.
Crystallization: The alignment or organization of atoms or molecules into a structure known as a crystal. Distillate: The condensed vapor product of distillation.
Distillation: The action of purifying a liquid by a process of heating and cooling. Ethanol: An alcohol made from starch-based plant materials through a complex fermentation and distillation process. Evaporation: The process of turning a liquid into a vapor. Extraction: The process of separating compounds via force or solvents. Extractor: The person, machine, or piece of equipment used for extraction. Falling Film Evaporator: A device used to separate compounds, specifically solvents from a solution.
Filter: To pass a liquid through a device to remove unwanted material. Freezer: A refrigerated compartment, cabinet, or room used for the preservation of goods in a cooled atmosphere. Full Spectrum: Containing all the compounds extracted from the original biomass. Gas: An expanded substance or matter having no fixed shape or volume.
Glassware: A variety of scientific equipment made of glass.
GRAS: Generally Recognized as Safe a designation of a substance by the Food and Drug Administration. Heptane: A nonpolar alkane hydrocarbon consisting of seven carbon atoms. Hot Plate: A Flat heated surface used for conduction. Hydrocarbon: A compound consisting of hydrogen and Carbon. Insoluble: (of a substance) incapable of being dissolved.
Isolate: A person, group, or thing that has been isolated. Lipids: Organic compounds such as epicuticular wax, fatty acids that can be removed through winterization.
Nonpolar: A molecule without positive or negative poles. Phase Change: The physical process of transition between the basic states of matter.
Polar: having electrical or magnetic polarity. Polarity: The separation of an electric charge which leads the molecule to have a positive and negative end. Post-Processing: The process of further refining extracted resin or tinctures. Propane: A three-carbon alkane used for extraction. Purge: The act or instance of eliminating contamination from a substance. Reactor: A glass or metal device used to mix a solution in a contained atmosphere.
Retention time: The amount of time a substance spends in contact with another substance.
Residence time: The average length of time during which a substance or an object is given in a location or condition. Rotary Evaporator: A device used for the separation of solvents from samples via evaporation through the rotation of the boiling flask. Saturation: The degree or extent to which something is dissolved or absorbed compared with the maximum possible. Saturation Limit: The maximum amount of a substance that can be dissolved within a solvent. Selectivity (solvent): The preferential dissolving of one component of a liquid or solid from a mixture than of another.
Soluble: (of a substance) able to be dissolved. Solubility: The ability of a given substance, the solute, to dissolve in a solvent. Solute: The minor component in a solution, dissolved in the solvent. Solution: A mixture in which the minor component is uniformly distributed into the major component to form a homogeneous mixture. Solvent: A material able to dissolve other substances. Solvent Recovery: The process of extracting useful materials from waste or by-product solvents generated during manufacturing. SOP (Standard Operating Procedure): A documented process set in place to ensure services or products are delivered consistently. Terpenes: Aromatic compounds present in most plants. Tri-Clamp: A quick-release mechanical joint for pipes, valves, or fittings in sanitary installations.
Vacuum: A space devoid of matter Vacuum Oven: A heated low-pressure environment used for delicate drying processes. Vapor: A substance in the gas phase. Vapor Pressure: The pressure exerted by a vapor in thermodynamic equilibrium with its condensed phase at a given temperature in a closed system. Viscosity: The thickness of a fluid. Winterization: The process of removing the lipids from a botanical extract by cooling and filtering.
HYDROCARBON EXTRACTION
10LB+ EVO Certified Closed Loop Extractor by BVV
Hydrocarbon extraction is a widely used botanicalextraction method that utilizes lighthydrocarbon solvents likebutane andpropane to extract botanical compounds.Hydrocarbon extractionis preferred by many botanicalextractors due to its high yields and lowsolvent recovery temperatures. These highly versatileextraction solvents lend themselves to producing a high purity botanical concentrate with little to nopost-processing.Hydrocarbons are a classification of organic compounds made from carbon and hydrogen.Hydrocarbons are formed due to the compression of animal and plant remains over long periods and are pulled from porous rocks where they pool and concentrate. These alkane molecules have an even distribution of electrons, making themnonpolarand well suited for extractingnonpolar botanical compounds.
The most commonly used hydrocarbons for botanical extraction include butaneand propane. These hydrocarbons can be utilized on their own to perform botanical extraction, or they can be combined into a blend of hydrocarbon solvents and utilized to extract a fuller spectrum of botanical compounds from biomass material. Typically a blend of n-butane, Isobutane, andpropaneis utilized to create an extractionsolvent with greater affinity to extract a wider variety of compounds found within botanical biomass resulting in a more full-spectrum extract.
120LB DIPTUBE Tank High Purity USA 70/30% N-Butane/Propane Blend By BVV
Bothbutane andpropane are class 1 group D flammable liquifiedgases that the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) have generally recognized as safe (GRAS). These lighthydrocarbons aregaseous at room temperature and ambient pressure where they are denser than air and tend to pool near the floor. When pressurized or placed under reduced temperature they become liquified and cansaturate biomass material and extractnonpolar botanical compounds.
20LB High Purity N-Butane By BVV
Hydrocarbons are the preferredextraction solvent of manyextractors looking to preserve highly volatile aromatic compounds due to their lowboiling point-1C/30.2F forbutane and -42C/-43.6F forpropane. Since thesesolvents boil off at a lower temperature than most aromatic compounds, they can be recovered with minimal heat preserving more aromatic compounds in comparison to other highboiling pointextraction solvents likeethanol. Whilebutane andpropane's lowboiling points lend themselves to aromatic compound preservation, it also makeshydrocarbons highly volatile and more hazardous to work with.
Although butane is generally recognized as safe by the FDA and can be consumed by humans in trace amounts, utilizing these highly volatile and flammable hydrocarbons as organic solvents under extreme temperatures and pressures can be dangerous. While it is highly unlikely that hydrocarbonextraction will result in an explosion when performed properly, when utilizing these highly flammable gases, there is always an inherent potential ignition. For this reason, any and all potential sources of heat or flame should be kept far away from areas in which hydrocarbon gases are present. To further mitigate the potential for ignition, hydrocarbon extraction should be performed inside of a C1D1extraction booth with all the proper safety and protective equipment.
C1D1 Explosion-Proof Booth By Advanced Extraction Labs
Among the most important pieces of safety equipment forhydrocarbon extraction is a C1D1extraction booth which greatly reduces the potential hazard when working withhydrocarbon solvents. A C1D1 hazardous location is where ignitablevapor concentrations exist under normal operating conditions and where a hazard is caused by frequent maintenance, repair work, or equipment failure.Hydrocarbon extraction typically falls under a Class 1 Division 1 environment because ignitable concentrations ofhydrocarbons exist under normal operating conditions. Depending on a specific municipality, the fire inspector may also require saidextraction booth to have a fireproof burn rating which is commonly required when dealing with larger volumes ofsolvent within the enclosed area.
C1D1 Hazardous locations require all electrical/electronics equipment to be designed, tested, and labeled acceptable for use in C1D1 areas. Beyond utilizing appropriately rated electrical/electronic components, mostextraction areas will come equipped with an explosion-proof exhaust fan providing a high air exchange rate, along with a lower explosive limitgas detector to alert high levels ofgas and trigger an increased rate of exhaust ventilation.
Lower Explosive Limit Gas Detector By Honeywell
While the use of appropriately rated electrical components within theextraction area drastically lowers the potential of a flammable substance being ignited, one of the more important functions of a C1D1extraction area is to reduce the risk of an explosion by regulating the airflow of the enclosed space to keep the levels ofgases below the lower explosive limit of the usedgas.
A C1D1extraction booth helps mitigate the risk of an explosion through the use of an explosion-proof exhaust fan, providing a high rate of air exchange. It comes with a lower explosive limitgas detector used to alert the user of high levels ofgas and trigger an increased rate of exhaust ventilation. When extracting withhydrocarbons, it's best to keep the percentage ofsolvent vapors within the enclosure well below 25% of their lower explosive limit which is 1.86% forbutane and 2.1%propane.
Portable Butane Leak Detector By BVV
When performing ahydrocarbon extraction inside a C1D1 rated Explosion-proof enclosure, only appropriately rated explosion-proof electronics should be utilized, and great care should be taken to limit exposure to open flame or static electricity by bonding metal containers during flammablesolvent transfer and grounding equipment. A C1D1 Environment is a must-have to safely and compliantly performhydrocarbon extraction and should be worked into the budget of every newhydrocarbon extraction lab build. While an explosion-proof environment significantly reduces risk duringhydrocarbon extraction, to ensure personal safety while performinghydrocarbon extraction, personal protective equipment in the form of safety goggles, nitrile gloves, antistatic clothing, and a respirator should be worn at all times.
When operating within a C1D1 environmenthydrocarbon extraction is typically performed utilizing a closed-loophydrocarbon extractor. A closed-loop systemallows for optimal safety as itcontains all flammablesolvents from theextraction process within a closed system and allows for the recapturing and reuse ofsolvent.
1LB MK-V Orthrus Bidirectional Flow Closed Loop Extractor By BVV
A typical closed-loop system can be broken down into three basic elements; Thesolvent tank/recovery tankwhere thehydrocarbon blend is stored and recondensed, the material column where the plant matter is loaded andsaturated, and the collection vessel where thebotanical extractsolution is collected and thesolvent evaporation process is performed. While these three components are essential to the operation of a closed-loop system, several additional components can be utilized to improve the efficiency of a closed-loop system.
5LB EVO Certified Closed Loop Extractor *49 State Certified By BVV
Common optional additions to a closed-loop system include adewax columnused to precipitate andfilter plant waxes from thesolution, acolor remediation columnused tofilter undesirable color pigments from the extract, and amolecular sieve columnused to absorb any water from thesolvent during thesolvent recovery process. While the function of a dewaxing column can be substituted by chilling theextraction solvent prior toextraction and limiting itsretention time, a molecular sieve and color remediation column are highly recommended to improve the overall efficiency of theextraction process. A color remediation column specifically is capable of drastically increasing the purity of the botanical extractand will be covered in great detail in the coming chapters.
2.5" InlineFilter Housing for Disposable Color Remediation Cartridges By AFS
Hydrocarbon extraction is performed simply bysaturating thebiomass material with a liquidhydrocarbon solvent. As the liquidsolvent saturates thebiomass, it dissolves compounds from the plant material. While this process is rather straightforward, several variables to the initialsaturation can be optimized to increase the overall yield and purity of the resulting extract. During the initialsaturation, the most effective variables to optimize the efficiency of ahydrocarbon extraction aresolvent temperature,solvent tobiomass ratio, andretention time.
Evo Elite Sleeved Solvent Tank By BVV
Solvent temperature is commonly altered either to increase the purity or overall yield of thehydrocarbon extraction. Theextractor may choose to either chill thesolvent to limit the pickup of impurities or extract using a room temperature or "warm"solvent to increase the overall yield of the extract. Duringextraction, the temperature of asolvent plays a big role in thesolubilityandsaturation capacity of asolvent.Saturation capacity andsolubility generally increase or decrease along with the temperature of thesolvent.
When a solvent is chilled prior to extraction, its overall solubility decreases, which helps limit the co-extraction of undesirable impurities such as plant waxes, lipids, and chlorophyll. This improved selectivity is a key advantage of cold extraction processes. However, the reduced extraction efficiency observed at lower temperatures is not solely a chemical solubility phenomenon. It is also driven by physical changes in the solvent itself.
As temperature decreases, solvent viscosity increases, causing the solvent to behave in a thicker, more honey-like manner. This increased viscosity reduces mass transfer efficiency by limiting the solvent’s ability to readily penetrate the biomass matrix, diffuse through cellular structures, and fully solvate target compounds.
As a result, target compound pickup can be partially suppressed—not because the compounds are insoluble, but because the solvent is physically less able to access and mobilize them. This effect can be compensated for by increasing the solvent-to-biomass ratio, extending contact or retention time, or optimizing flow dynamics to restore adequate mass transfer while preserving the benefits of reduced impurity pickup.
Unistat 825 Dynamic Temperature Control / Circulation Thermostat By Huber
Hydrocarbon solvent is typically chilled within a -20C to -80C (-4F to -112F) range, increasing theselectivity of theextraction and limiting the co-extraction of impurities. Common methods of chillinghydrocarbon solvent include aninjection coilsubmerged in dry ice that thehydrocarbon solvent runs through prior to injection of the material column or ajackedsolvent tankconnected to arefrigerated circulatorto chill thehydrocarbon solvent prior to the initialsaturation.
Stainless Steel Injection Coil By BVV
Conversely, a room temperature or "warm"hydrocarbon solvent can be utilized to perform the initialsaturation. When utilizing a room temperature or "warm"hydrocarbon extraction, thesolvent has greatersolubility andsaturation capacity allowing thesolvent to more effectively dissolve target compounds from the plant matter. While this strategy allows for the target compounds to be more effectively dissolved from the plant matter, it also allows undesirable botanical compounds like color pigments and plant waxes to be more easily dissolved, resulting in a greater number of total impurities. Commonly, a warmextraction is paired with inline adsorbent filtration utilizing acolor remediation columnallowing for efficientextraction of the target compounds during the initialsaturation and removing undesired impurities through filteringresulting in high yield and purity.
Color Remediation Column By BVV
Regardless of theextraction temperature strategy, once thesolvent has reached the desiredextraction temperature, thesolvent is then injected into the material columnsaturating thebiomass material. There are two methodologies forsaturating thebiomass material. Closing the outlet to the material column allows the material column to fill withsolvent and fullysaturate the plant matter increasingretention timebefore draining thesolventinto the collection vessel. Another way is to leave the outlet of the material column open, allowing thesolvent to quickly pass through the material column into the collection vessel, limitingsolvent retention timefor what is referred to as a quick wash.Retention timeis an important factor in allowing thesolvent to dissolve the target compounds. Too littleretention timecan result in reduced yield of target compounds, while too longretention timecan allow more undesirable compounds likechlorophyll and plant waxes to be dissolved.
Extended retention timesare great for extracting everything from the plant matter. When this strategy is paired with inline adsorbent filtration, it can result in both high yield and purity. Conversely, a shortretention timeallows for greater purity by minimizing the time thesolvent has to co-extract undesirables. When a quick wash/shortretention timestrategy is utilized in conjunction with chilledsolvent, it can result in a concentrate with very low levels of impurities. Utilizing a shortretention timeand chilledsolvent typically results in lower extract yield. This can be combated by utilizing a highersolvent tobiomass ratio to ensure the majority of the target compounds are extracted while limiting the pickup of undesirable color pigments and plant waxes. Typically, asolventtobiomass ratio of 3-5:1 is commonly utilized to perform ahydrocarbon extraction. Up to a 10:1 ratio can be utilized when extracting with coldsolventto ensure the majority of the desired compounds are extracted.
20LB High Purity N-Butane By BVV
Thesolvent tobiomass ratio is the final factor in the initialsaturation that can be optimized. Most commonly, a ratio between 3-5 pounds ofhydrocarbon solvent will be utilized for every 1 lb ofbiomass loaded into the material column. The greater the total volume ofsolventutilized during the initialsaturation, the greater theextraction efficiency. Moresolvent used for the initialsaturation typically allows for more of the target compounds to be dissolved from the plant matter. An increasedsolvent tobiomass ratio is especially useful when utilizing a quick wash, short retention timesaturation strategy. While this ratio can be further increased to ensure the target compounds are extracted from the plant matter it results in a greater total volume ofsolvent used, increasing production costs, extending thesolvent recovery process, and increasing overall runtime.
19 Liter Neocision Heated Circulator - ETL Listed By BVV
After the initialsaturation is complete and the entirety of thebotanical extract-richhydrocarbon solution has been drained into the collection vessel, the bulk of thesolvent recovery process is performed by heating thesolution toevaporate thehydrocarbon solvent from thebotanical extractsolution. Thesolvent recovery process is adistillation process initiated by applying heat to the extractsolution toevaporate theextraction solvent from thebotanical extractand the condensation of the ensuingsolvent vapors inside a chilledrecovery tank. Typically thesolution is heated by either submerging the collection vessel in a hot water bath or recirculating hot water through the jacket of the collection base.
4 Cylinder Butane Recovery Pump By BVV
Thesolvent recovery process can be performed utilizing two separate methodologies: activesolvent recovery or passivesolvent recovery. Both passive and activesolvent recovery utilize heat applied to the collection toevaporate thesolvent from the extract and cool therecovery tank to condense thehydrocarbon vapors inside a vessel separate from the extract. Activerecovery assists thesolvent recovery process by including arecovery pumpthat aids in the transfer and compression of thegaseous solvent, speeding up thesolvent recovery process. While both methodologies have their benefits and drawbacks, both can be utilized to recoverhydrocarbon solvents effectively.
MVP150 Explosion Proof Recovery Pump By Master Vapor Pumps
Regardless of thesolvent recoverymethodology, the collection vessel containing the extractsolution is heated to initiate thesolvent recovery process. Therecovery tank is chilled and commonly pulled undervacuum only if thesolvent tank is empty to create pressure and temperature differential between the heated collection base and the chilledrecovery tank. This pressure and temperature differential between the two vessels results in thesolvent vapors being attracted to the lower pressure and temperaturerecovery tank once the process connections between the two are opened.
DOT-Approved Recovery Cylinders By Mastercool
Note that if therecovery tank containssolvent, do not attempt to pull therecovery tank undervacuum assolvent vapors can be pulled out of the vessel into thevacuum pump, potentially causing ignition of thesolvent vapor. While reduced pressure within therecovery tank assists in the travel ofvapor from the collection vessel to therecovery tank, if therecovery tank still hassolventwithin it, thesolventrecovery process can still be performed relying solely on the temperature differential between the two vessels. However, the pressure from the collection vessel must be greater than the pressure within therecovery tank, which can be ensured by keeping therecovery tank as cold as possible during therecovery procedure.
BVV-80C Chiller By BVV
During thesolvent recovery process, the movement of thesolvent vapor within the system operates under the principle thatgas always seeks the lowest pressure region of a system. The pressure of ahydrocarbon gas directly correlates to its temperature by heating thehydrocarbon solvent within the collection tank, thus increasing its pressure. Moreover, by cooling thesolvent recovery tank the ensuingvapors naturally are pulled towards the lower pressure chilledrecovery tank where they are condensed and their pressure is reduced.
Neocision 5 Liter Heated Circulator - ETL Listed By BVV
The efficiency of thesolvent recoveryprocess is a function of the heat applied to the collection vessel and the amount of cooling applied to thesolvent tank. Sincehydrocarbon solvents have relatively lowboiling points, light heat is sufficient to perform theevaporative process. While increased heat can help speed up thesolvent recovery process, it is a double-edged sword as it may degrade orevaporate the more volatile compounds typically found in thebotanical extractliketerpenes. During this process, it is important to keep in mind the lowestboiling pointof the compounds to be preserved, and stay under that temperature when determining the heat level to apply to thesolvent recovery process.
Stainless Steel Condensing Coil By BVV
The other side of thissolvent distillation process is the condensation ofsolvent vapors inside therecovery tank. Condensation happens whenvapor is cooled or condensed past its condensation point and is initiated by the molecular clustering ofvapor within agaseous volume or at the contact ofvapor with a cool enough liquid or surface. This process can be assisted through the use of acondensing coilsubmerged in dry ice, which provides a high surface area low-temperature zone wherevaporscan be condensed before entering therecovery tank. Typically the colder therecovery tank or condensing coil, the more efficiently thesolvent will be recovered and collected.
7.5CF Neocision Vacuum Oven - ETL Certified By BVV
While it is typical for the bulk of thehydrocarbon solventto be recovered during this time, depending on the specific type of extract to be produced, more or lesshydrocarbon solvent may be left to be recovered by thevacuum oven or used to performevaporative crystallization. This will be covered in-depth in the isolation chapter.
Certified Jacketed Diamond Miner By BVV
After the desired amount of the hydrocarbon solvent has been recovered, The recovery tank and collection vessels are isolated, and the collection vessel is depressurized after the desired amount of the hydrocarbon solvent has been recovered. The extract is then harvested from the closed-loop system. The residual amount of hydrocarbon solvent remaining within the extract is purged utilizing a vacuum oven, covered in-depth in Chapter 4: Solvent Recovery/Purging. Once the extract has been purged of all residual solvent, it can be further refined through distillation or utilized for infusion in some cases.
1.9CF NeocisionVacuum Oven By BVV
After the closed-loopsolvent recovery process has been performed and the extract has been harvested from the closed-loop system thehydrocarbonextraction procedure is complete and the resulting extract can bepurged of residualsolventand further refined. Now that we have covered the properhydrocarbon extraction safety protocols andextraction methodologies let's dive deeper into theextraction preparation and actual operation of a closed-loop system.
Hydrocarbon extraction starts with packing the material column withbiomass material and proper assembly of theextractor. During the packing of the material column, botanicalbiomass is loaded into the material column and packed as evenly as possible to reduce channeling of thesolution and tight enough to fit the desired amount of material within the column while still being able to agitate the material by hand. Once the material is loaded into the material column, it is important to remove any debris from thetri-clampferrules to ensure a tight seal between the tri-clampgasket and the endcaps continuing the assembly of the material column.
Packing Rod for Material Tubes By BVV
Once the material column has been packed and assembled, continue to assemble the remainder of the system. While assembling theextractor, ensure that all high-pressure clamps are tightened with a torque wrench to manufacturer specification (typically 110 inches per sqft). After assembly, prior to initiating ahydrocarbon extraction, a pre-assembly inspection and testing of theextractor should always be done to ensure safety duringextraction. During the inspection, confirm that all gaskets are free of visible wear and ensure all lines and fittings are intact and appropriately tightened before pressure testing the system.
Glycerine Filled Compound Gauge By BVV
After assembly and preinspection of the closed-loopextractor, it is important to pressure test the system to ensure no leaks. A leak within the system can result inhydrocarbon solvent escaping from the system and being released into the atmosphere. To ensure safety duringextraction, it is always recommended to pressure test the system after the reassembly of a closed-loopextraction system. To initiate a pressure test, start by ensuring the outlet to the sourcesolventtank is closed and then open all process flow valves from the closed sourcesolvent tank to the collection tank and pressurize the system with nitrogen to 100 PSI. Once the system has reached 100 PSI, close the nitrogen input valve and allow the system to be held under pressure for at least 30 minutes prior toextraction to ensure pressure can be held.
BUNA SanitaryTri-ClampScreen Gaskets By Rubber Fab
If pressure is not held during this time, identify where pressure leaks are coming from by spraying all process connections with soapy water. If the process connection is leaking, it will be observed to create additional bubbles. Once a pressure leak has been identified, depressurize the system and disassemble and reassemble the system as necessary, making sure to replace any parts no longer holding a seal. Once reassembled, proceed to pressure test the system again, and disassemble and reassemble as needed until pressure can be maintained. At BVV, we pressure test every vessel at 100 PSI for 24 hours prior to shipment upon disassembly and reassembly of the unit. The same is always recommended, but a shorter pressure test can be utilized at the discretion of theextractor.
Once the system has passed the pressure test prepare thehydrocarbon solvent forextraction by bringing it to the desiredextraction temperature. If utilizing a newsolvent, it is always recommended to distill thesolvent to eliminate the risk of contamination from the storagesolvent tank before bringing it to the desiredextraction temperature.
120LB High PurityPropane tank By BVV
To distill freshsolvent, start by first bonding the sourcesolvent tank to the groundedextractor before injectinghydrocarbon solventfrom the sourcesolvent tank into the collection vessel of the pressure tested closed-loophydrocarbon extractor. Once loaded, close the valve to thesolvent storage tank and proceed to heat the collection with a hot water bath to 38C/100F. During this time, it is important to also chill down therecovery tank to condense the ensuingvapors. Once the collection vessel andrecovery tank have reached their operating temperature, open all process connection valves between the collection vessel and therecovery tank and proceed toevaporate thesolvent from the collection vessel, recondensing it back into therecovery tank. Once all thesolvent has beenevaporated from the collection vessel and condensed into therecovery tank, close thevapor valve on therecovery tank, depressurize the closed-loop system, and disassemble the collection vessel. Clean the inside of the collection tank withethanol to remove any residue from the freshly distilledsolvent.
Now that thesolvent has been distilled and the collection vessel has been cleaned of any residue, proceed to reassemble the system as normal. This will ensure that the system is assembled to manufacture specification, all high-pressure clamps are torqued to specification, and all process connections are secure and appropriately tightened. After assembly, proceed to pressure test the system again for a minimum of 30 minutes to ensure proper assembly before preparing for the initialextraction.
Now that the fresh solvent has been distilled, proceed to bring the solvent to the desired extraction temperature while pulling the remainder of the extraction system under vacuum. Pulling the system under vacuum evacuates ambient pressure from the system, creating a low-pressure zone that allows the hydrocarbon solvent to move through the system more easily and provides a clean atmosphere for the extraction process to be performed. Additionally, pulling an EMPTY recovery tank under vacuum prior to initiating the recovery process creates a low-pressure zone for the solvent vapors to be pushed/pulled towards during recovery.
12CFM Two-Stage Spark FreeVacuum Pump By BVV
Before pulling the system undervacuum, start by ensuring thesolvent tank is closed off and no residualvapors are within the system. Ifhydrocarbon vapors are pulled into a standardvacuum pump, it could cause ignition ofhydrocarbon vapors. Once thesolvent tank has been confirmed to be closed, open all process connections from the closed sourcesolvent tank to the collection vessel. Connect thevacuum line from the collectionvacuum valve to an intrensically safe vacuum pump. Ensure all process connections are tightened appropriately and proceed to turn on thevacuum pump and allow the system to be pulled undervacuum to -29.9hg before closing thevacuum valve and turning off thevacuum pump. Once the system has been pulled undervacuum,isolate each component of theextraction system by closing all input and output valves and allowing thehydrocarbon solvent to reach the desiredextraction temperature.
Once theextraction solventreaches the desired temperature, theextraction can be initiated by transferring thesolvent from thesolvent tank to the material column. If thesolvent is warm, thesolvent will have its own inherent pressure that can be utilized to inject thesolvent into the material column due to the pressure differential being pulled under avacuum. While this pressure differential is typically sufficient in the transfer from thesolvent tank to the material column, if thesolvent is chilled enough to reduce the pressure of thehydrocarbon solvent, then nitrogen can be utilized to push thesolvent from therecovery tank into the material column of the system. In both cases, nitrogen can push thesolventinto the material column by first pressurizing thesolvent tank to the desired injection pressure. While higher pressures can be utilized to inject thesolvent, 10-25 PSI is typically sufficient in transferring thesolvent into the material column.
Explosion Proof Platform Scale By BVV
Once thesolvent tank has been pressurized appropriately, place the LPrecovery tank on anexplosion-proof scale. Tare the scale and open the process connection valves from the sourcesolvent tank to the material column, injecting the desired amount ofsolvent into the material column, allowing thebiomass material to besaturated. If utilizing a quick washsolvent saturation strategy, ensure the process connection valves from the outlet of the material column to the collection vessel are open, allowing thesolvent to drain into the collection vessel upon injection. If utilizing a longersaturation, ensure the material column outlet valve is closed, allowing the material to be completely submerged in asolvent for the desired retention timebefore draining theextraction solution to the collection vessel. Once the entirety of theextraction solution has made its way into the collection vessel, proceed to initiate thesolvent recovery process.
To initiate the recovery of solvent within a closed-loop hydrocarbon extractor, start by closing the inlet valve to the collection vessel and then chill down the solvent tank and heat the collection vessel. If the recovery tank is empty, isolate the recovery tank and pull it under vacuum to create a lower pressure zone for vapors to be pulled towards. Depending on the boiling point of the target compounds to be preserved within the botanical extract, more or less heat may be applied to preserve these compounds. Typically the collection vessel will be heated to a temperature range between 20C/68F and 37C/100F to evaporate the hydrocarbon solvent. The application of heat to the collection vessel can be applied by submerging the collection vessel in a hot water bath or recirculating hot water through the jacket of the collection vessel utilizing a heated circulator.
7 Liter heated Circulator By Polyscience
Commonly thesolvent tank will be chilled as cold as possible by either submerging therecoverytank and condensing coil in a dry ice/ethanol slurry or circulating chilled fluid through the jacket of thesolvent tank utilizing arefrigerated circulator. Once both the collection vessel and therecovery tank have reached the desired temperature, initiate thesolvent recovery process by opening all process connection valves between the collection vessel and therecovery tank. If utilizing an activerecovery pump, turn it on at this time. During this time, closely monitor the extract within the collection vessel to gauge thesolvent recovery process. Thesolventrecovery process can be continued until the extract completely solidifies. No more boiling is observed, requiring it to be scraped out of the collection vessel. It can also be stopped once only a small amount of theextraction solvent remains to allow the extract to be poured or drained from the collection vessel andpurging the remainder of thesolvent utilizing avacuum oven.
Once thesolvent recovery process has been performed to theextractors liking,isolate thesolvent tank and collection vessel, turn off therecovery pump if utilized, depressurize the closed-loopextractor, and harvest the extract. Once the extract has been harvested, proceed to thevacuum purging procedure outlined In Chapter 4:Solvent recovery/Purging.
HYDROCARBON EXTRACTION STANDARD OPERATING PROCEDURE
Purpose
The purpose of this procedure is to provide detailed instructions for closed-loophydrocarbon extraction.
Scope
This procedure applies to all lab technicians tasked with closed-loophydrocarbon extraction.
Definitions/Acronyms
Personal Protection Equipment (PPE)Items worn to protect employees from exposure to hazardous materials and prevention of injury.
Safety Data Sheet (SDS)Provides useful information on chemicals, describing the hazards the chemical presents, and giving information on handling, storage, and emergency measures in case of an accident.
Load the material column with the desired amount ofbiomass material packing the material tightly and evenly.
Clear any excessbiomassfrom the tri-clampferrules and fully assemble the remainder of the material column ensuring that all high-pressure clamps are torqued to manufacture specification.
Proceed to assemble the remainder of the system ensuring all clamps are torqued to manufacturer specifications and all process connection hoses are secured and tightened properly.
Once thehydrocarbon system assembly is complete proceed to pressure test the system by first ensuring the sourcesolvent tank is closed and all process connections are open from the closedsolvent tank to the collection vessel.
Proceed to inject nitrogen into the injection manifold of the extractor pressurizing the system to 100 PSI before isolating the system.
Allow the system to remain under pressure for a minimum of 30 minutes to ensure the system is assembled correctly with no leaks.
If the pressure within the system drops below 100PSI proceed to spray all process connections with soapy water to identify where the leak is coming from. If bubbling is observed at a process connection, a pressure leak has been identified.
Once the pressure leak has been identified, depressurize the system and disassemble and reassemble as necessary before repressurizing the system again and disassembling and reassembling the system as needed until pressure is maintained.
Once pressure is held within the system for a minimum of 30 minutes proceed to depressurize the system and proceed to pull the system undervacuum.
Attach aspark-freevacuum pumpto the collection base of the closed-loop system and open all process flow valves from the collection vessel to the closed sourcesolvent tank ensuring the sourcesolvent tank valve is fully closed.
Turn on thespark-freevacuum pumpand allow adequate time for the entire system to be pulled undervacuum. Once the system has reached -29.9mmHg close thevacuum valve, turn off the spark-free pump, and close all processing flow valves on the system isolating each component.
Proceed to bond thesolvent andrecovery tanks and transfer 3-5 lbs of distilledhydrocarbon solvent for every 1lb ofbiomass you plan to extract into thesolvent recovery tank of the closed-loopextraction system and proceed to chill thesolvent recovery tank to the desired temperature through the use of dry ice or an appropriately sized chiller.
Once thesolvent has reached the desired injection temperature, proceed to start your initialextraction.
7. Procedure
Pressurize therecovery solvent tank with nitrogen to the desired injection pressure 10-25PSI and open all processing valves from therecovery solvent tank to the material column,saturating the material column at a 3-5:1 ratio (solvent: material).
After the desiredsaturation of the material column has been achieved, open all processing valves from the material column to the collection vessel allowing the entirety ofbotanical extractsolution to flow into the collection vessel.
Once the entirety of thesolution has been transferred into the collection vessel close the collection vessel inlet valve.
Proceed to initiatesolvent recovery by submerging the collection base in a hot water bath or turning on theheated recirculatorsetting the temperature to the desiredsolvent recovery temperature and proceeding to chill therecovery tank to the desired temperature using a dry ice/ethanol slurry or an appropriate refrigerated circulator.
Once the collection vessel andsolvent recovery tank have reached the desiredsolvent recovery temperatures open the process connections between the collection vessel and therecovery tank to start thesolvent recovery process.
Proceed to recover thehydrocarbon solvent until only extract remains,isolate therecovery tank, depressurize the closed-loop system, and drain or harvest thebotanical extractinto a clean receptical.
Once thebotanical extracthas been harvested proceed to thevacuum purging procedure.
Disassembly and cleaning
Depressurize the closed-loop system to ambient pressures by opening the input/output valves on the material column and collection base.
Once each gauge reads 0PSI proceed to disassemble the system by removing the high-pressure clamps and disposing of the spendbiomass material.
Proceed to clean and sanitize all parts with200 proofethanolto remove any particulate, oil, or other contaminants.